I recently picked up an audio recording of Ann Patchett’s Run, curious as I was to read her fiction after reading her memoir Truth & Beauty, about her friendship with Lucy Grealy, author of Autobiography of a Face.
While Run was a decent novel, I was more stunned by what Patchett said in an interview following the audio recording. According to the publisher/interviewer, it took Patchett six years to write Run, and at the same time, she’d produced Truth & Beauty.
The interviewer asked, “Was the act of writing nonfiction at the same time interference, or did it help clarify things for you, or did it make no difference whatsoever?”
Patchett replied, “It really made no difference. Writing nonfiction is so much easier than writing fiction—for me—that it really is akin to saying, ‘I did my shopping list, and then I went back to my novel.’”
What! In my writing circle, we grit our jaws and wipe back tears as we slowwwwly weave our memories into story, and Ann Patchett has the nerve to say that, for her, nonfiction is like writing a shopping list.
Granted, she’s more seasoned than most of us, but I think the success of Patchett’s Truth & Beauty relies heavily on the aura of Lucy Grealy, the tragic artist—the lurid story of neediness, depression, reckless spending, promiscuity, and drug addiction behind Grealy’s triumphant, hopeful Autobiography of a Face. I thought there were key elements missing from Truth & Beauty, particularly exploration of Patchett’s inner life as she served as Grealy’s quasi-suicide hotline.
How could she not have felt annoyance and resentment as Grealy called her several times a day to ask if she loved her? To bemoan that nobody loved her. My gods, who could put up with that—and why? And how did Patchett deal with the guilt, if any, that she made the decision not to contact Grealy about her coming into town the night that Grealy died of a drug overdose?
If what we wanted was an exposé on Grealy’s brokenness, we got it. It’s hard for me, though, to trust a narrator who guards herself in a self-portrait of saintly patience. (Patchett does reference this in the book, when Grealey wonders what she’s done to deserve her loyal friendship and says, “But at least I can make you feel like a saint. That’s what you’ve always wanted.”)
Nonfiction is “easy” to write when we write about another person’s problems and risk little of ourselves.